~*Revealing and Getting Rid of Scams | Creating Honest Sustainable Wealth | Offering Happiness, Safety and Legitimacy*~

Saturday, 30 July 2011

Are Retirement Calculators Reliable?

by Walter Updegrave

Based on my age, investments and the amount I'm saving, an online calculator suggested that my chances of being able to retire with the money I'll need is a virtual slam dunk. How confident can I be that my investments will actually earn enough over the next 40 years for me to retire? -- D.M.

I'm not a math wiz or a quant by any stretch of the imagination. But when it comes to making retirement planning decisions, I think it's important to look at the numbers.

That said, whenever you rev up an online tool or calculator, you've got to remember that you're dealing with estimates (often very squishy ones) not certainties. So common sense dictates that you take the results with more than a couple grains of salt.

Let's take the case of retirement calculators. Most project how large a nest egg you might accumulate -- and, in many cases, how long it might last -- based on a number of factors, including how much you've already accumulated, how much more you plan to save, how many years until you retire, the rate of return your investments will earn and how long you'll live.

You don't need a finance degree to know that all of these factors involve more than a little uncertainty. It's one thing to say you plan to save $500 a month or 15% of your salary for the next three or four decades and plug that assumption into a calculator.

It's another thing to actually do it. Reality often intrudes. Companies downsize, kids need orthodontia, college bills zap savings and sometimes the will to save yields to the urge to spend.

Projecting investment returns doesn't exactly lend itself to precision either. Forecasters generally start with a long-term expected return that builds in some variation -- both up and down -- since it's clear that investments like stocks and bonds don't churn out identical returns year after year.

Typically, the expected return is based on historical average returns for various asset classes or projected averages based on how returns might unfold given today's conditions.

Either way, there's as much art as science in determining this, as even when you're dealing with historical data, averages can vary substantially depending on the period you choose.

For example, the bible for investments stats, the Ibbotson SBBI Classic Yearbook, shows that from 1926 through 2010, the annualized return for large-company stocks was 9.9%. But there were many relatively long stretches over that span when stocks' annualized return was much higher (20.1% for the 10 years from 1948 through 1958) and much lower (-1.4% for 1999 through 2008).

[Note to purists: I know that investment firms use arithmetic averages, not geometric averages or annualized returns, to build forecasts. But individual investors are more accustomed to seeing annualized rather than arithmetic returns -- which for stocks would be considerably higher -- so I cite annualized figures to avoid confusion.]

My point is that, even people who take a meticulous approach can come away with different ideas of what investments might earn in the future. That's the nature of prognostication.

At the same time, you must also be careful of falling into the "recency" trap, or basing your estimates on what's happened lately. It would be just as wrongheaded to presume the rough times we're experiencing today represent our long-term future as it was to assume (as many did at the time) that the boom times of the '90s marked the beginning of a golden era of unabated prosperity.

And, indeed, most rigorous attempts to forecast returns try to avoid merely accepting past averages or extrapolating recent experience into the future. (For a look at how two recent forecasts do that, click here and here).

So what does all this mean for someone trying to get a handle on his retirement planning? It's great to come away from a session with a retirement calculator with good news.

But just to be on the safe side, do a little reality check. Maybe try another calculator to see if the results are at least in the same ballpark. I'd also advise running a few different scenarios to see how that affects the results.

A young person like you with some 40 years to go until retirement probably has a relatively aggressive investment portfolio, say, 80% or more in stocks. If that's the case, try re-running the numbers with more conservative mixes, say, 60% stocks -- 40% bonds or even 50% stocks -- 50% bonds.

You'll likely find that your odds of success are somewhat lower -- or, that you'll have to boost the amount you're saving each year in order to maintain those better odds of success.

The extent to which the odds drop, shows how much you're counting on the higher expected returns of stocks to achieve a comfortable retirement. If those gains materialize, that's fine. But you don't want your retirement prospects to collapse if those returns fall short.

So to be safe, you may want to set your savings targets based a more moderate investing strategy. Save a bit more so that you're still OK if your investments earn less than the return projected with a more stock-heavy portfolio (or if you happen to miss your savings targets in some years).

And remember that no tool or calculator can predict the future. That's especially true when you're looking decades ahead. Over the 40 years between now and the time you retire there are just too many unknowns. Neither you, nor I, nor anyone else can control how the economy or the financial markets will perform.

What you can do, though, is check your progress periodically -- say, every year or so -- and adjust your overall savings and investing strategy to stay on track as you draw closer to your planned retirement date. Do that, and you can rest assured you are doing all you can.

Copyrighted, CNNMoney. All Rights Reserved.


Anonymous said...

Your mode of eхplaining all in this post is аctuаlly nice, eѵery one be capаble of simply understаnԁ it,
Тhanκs a lot.

Look into my web ρage: chatroulette

Anonymous said...

In the four tournaments since his first of the season,
he. A bowler who can consistently pick up his spares can
easily hold a 180 average without getting any strikes.

It's fast to build and play and will challenge your memory.

My blog: kostenlos spielen -

Anonymous said...

Entertainment industry and other business establishments
have seen a heavy growth with the number of online
applications developed. In addition to music, they broadcast
preaching and teaching from Jimmy Swaggert and other pastors and
teachers who work with the ministry. So you can imagine how much your choice has increased from before.

Also visit my weblog

Anonymous said...

The new EP Pure Wet is a masterclass in experimental baselines and echoey, breathy vocals all underpinned by varying funk and R&B-based rhythms.
At a bargain 100 bolivianos for 4 hours, they have enough power to get 2 gringo-sized riders up the
local hills. We are literally not the same person we were
a minute ago, let alone a day, a month or a year ago.

Take a look at my page Author's external home page...

Anonymous said...

s better to use whole foods made from scratch for good health.
Avocados- Although not my favorite, are high in fats, the good ones.
Many people don't have the time to weight themselves every day, but checking the scale on a regular basis can definitely help when you're working to lose weight and
keep it off.

Here is my page ...

Anonymous said...

If you cannot write love poems for your guy,
don't be disappointed easily. Once she moved 1931 to Krakow with her family, she lived and worked there since her death in February of last year. On the other hand children spend most of their time with their mothers, who love deeply, scold harshly, they worry extremely but in the end they make you what you are.

Here is my web page -

Anonymous said...

She is likely a WARRIOR PERSONALITY I talk
about in the KWML Mastery Course on women, dating, love, and friendship.
Then came the ultra-popular Arkham games, that place you, like never before,
into Batman's shoes as he skulks around and knocks hoodlums heads together (literaly). It's fast to
build and play and will challenge your memory.

my webpage: simply click the next site -

Anonymous said...

It is the A Funeral Poem which can lift the soul of these small children, though they may not even know
what death means. Choosing to focus on sound as a restriction increases a
poet's powers of observation in melodic structure and the inherit oral aspects of a poem. Remember fall in love poems should say the exact thing you feel without hesitation and fear of being embarrassed, either you write fall in love poems yourself or choose from the famous fall in love poems.

Also visit my web site

Anonymous said...

Literally wiping sweat from my forehead after doing my best 90s dance moves to a memorable mix of old school joints from the likes of Special Ed, Eric B.
Remember that most dorm room radio stations out there may or may not be online from time
to time and that cannot be blamed on the app, however this does hinder the experience of Internet radio on the i
- Phone. This is a fantastic app for people who
travel and it now supports multitasking.

Here is my website internetradio

Anonymous said...

That's like Houston Texas being without a Country station. They also apparently believe that their customers who like a particular song they hear on the radio, are likely to purchase that song, which could add to downloads from i - Tunes. You will need an outside antenna to get clear reception on your radio.

my website; radio navigation system rns 310 price

Anonymous said...

Congress tried in 2007 to pass a measure that would lock in the rate that
could be charged through 2010 at 7. In my case I listen to
all music that is submitted to me before I include it on
my playlist. With the Worldmate Nokia 5800 Xpress - Music application you can keep track of
the current times in up to five different cities
worldwide at a go.

my web-site ...

Anonymous said...

In most cases they are, but when it comes to updates, patches, etc to the mmorpgs.
If you don’t have much skill in programming, but still think that creating and developing games
is the most suitable for you, there are special courses
that will give you training in graphic designing, game development, and computer animation.
Next Jim Deacove developed a few of his own board games based on the principles of cooperation, group strategy and joint problem solving.

Take a look at my weblog: visit the next website

Anonymous said...

Your should see something similar to the illustration above.

If you already have your Facebook fan or business page created
you will need to have 25 fans or "LIKES" in order to create a custom URL.

Link ' Recommend sites to other users and vice versa.

my website -

Anonymous said...

You can use Opera Mobile to save web pages for later viewing even
when offline. If you are selling a certain product you may
want to pair up with someone that can help you. Kostenlos Spiele
Downloaden Weitere Verbesserungen Spielgrafiken Möglich wurden inbegriffen derjenige Einführung
dieser FM-Synthese-Sound.

Here is my blog Videos Von Myvideo Downloaden

Anonymous said...

However, you must know how to be able to effectively utilize
the tools for you to essentially fully use the website.
You might not allow people to write on your wall,
however, when you share a thought, a link, or comment on someone's else wall, people can definitely also leave a comment. If you're
looking to use social networking to advance or
enhance your career than sites like Linked In, Career Builder,
and Monster make sense to utilize.

my blog post ... facebook fans kaufen

Anonymous said...

The new EP Pure Wet is a masterclass in experimental baselines and echoey, breathy vocals all underpinned by varying funk and R&B-based rhythms.
One of the key reasons for this effect is that these types of music utilize a tempo
between 55 and 85 beats per minute. It is a very capable digital audio
editor, that has multiple options for remixing and refining the various sounds you
can create.

Look at my page chillout radio

Anonymous said...

But, internet radio offers a whole lot more than just your
favorite music online. "Mike" is Mike Dean, according to the scanty information available, and beyond that there's not much about him. Given the manner in which the internet and the World Wide Web have invaded our lives over the past many years, it is hardly surprising that music or rather the radio would be one of the areas being dominated by the internet.

my site -

Anonymous said...

Too many folks have already thrown away plenty of good
money on nothing but useless salt tablets being shipped from South America.
For many working to lose weight, one failure is enough to get them off the path to success.
That way, the actual process will end up being much less frustrating and,
for the majority of people, enjoyable.

Feel free to visit my web-site;

Anonymous said...

Enjoy the public open-air concept loo and shower area.
At a bargain 100 bolivianos for 4 hours, they have enough power to get 2 gringo-sized riders
up the local hills. We are literally not the same person we were a minute ago, let alone a day, a month or a year ago.

Also visit my page :: chillout radio

Anonymous said...

If it is not, remove the receiving part of the mouse, the device plugged into the USB port,
then reinsert it. Which means that you will only end up
spending $47 on this unit. These buttons are a very cool feature for the mouse, so if you've never used a feature like this before, don't be too intimidated
not to try them out.

My homepage; Logitech - Headset -

Anonymous said...

Broadcast satellite "in the Star on the 9th," was successfully launched in June
last year, it can be said is a milestone in the field of live satellite
event. So your personal, non-commercial, watercraft is exempt from a licensing requirement.
Another radio commercial production tip to chew on is to make sure the audio quality is excellent on any spot your produce.

my web blog ... Radio rodja bandung

Anonymous said...

I read this paragraph сompletely about thе rеѕemblance of hottest and preνious technologies, іt's amazing article.

Here is my webpage - cure hemorrhoids

Anonymous said...

These are radio stations that specialize in different genres of music including
Soul, Jam, Jazz, and Country music, Gospel, Hip Hop and
Rap. These gadgets also have USB ports where you can also connect any
device you have. Such was the beginning of a journey
that would propel Ms.

my weblog :: Internet Radio

Anonymous said...

They want to win by playing their very best as opposed to winning by putting the
other person off. By obtaining increasingly more favour using their company people in
your social settings, the more handle you will need to acquire what you would like,
and thru The particular Coalition Game you have just about the most effective tips for hypnotherapy that gives you the talent to ensure that
you influence other folks. Online gaming is a popular way to
spend enjoyable time at a low cost for hours on end.

Here is my webpage ... video game addiction rehab

Anonymous said...

Carter's gloves slip on the safety buckles; the mud has invaded every crevice of the uniform. In the minority of minorities, his opinion of the Barack is that he will turn the USA into a liberal hippie haven where gays and blacks will be exalted like Angelina Jolie. We learn from history that we learn nothing from history.

Here is my web blog :: Author's external home page.


Anonymous said...

What you want to discuss and how you discuss various issues is left to you, which again is an advantage especially if you are creating an online talk radio station.

This is true simulation of the traditional transmission of radio and television programs, as it is only a
station house music on your PC. This powerful
and versatile solution is also available in three different versions,
so you should have no trouble finding the perfect one for you.

Look into my web page; internet radio australia

Anonymous said...

In other trick taking games, players can take tricks on a number of kind of contract.
The player who spins the coin is referred to as the spinner.
Moreover, there you could also play Scrabble in the internet,
TV game shows or game consoles.

Feel free to surf to my web blog:

Anonymous said...

Here is an explanation of the ten major poetic forms.
Friendship Collection: a beautiful selection of
friendship audio poems to share with your closest
friends. On the other hand children spend most of their time with
their mothers, who love deeply, scold harshly, they
worry extremely but in the end they make you what you are.

Anonymous said...

This involves setting a line of hundreds, or even thousands, of baited hooks
near the surface of the ocean to catch bluefin tuna.
The different characteristics that you need to consider are breaking strength, diameter, durability, abrasion resistance, flexibility, stretch, knot strength and
importantly visibility. To get hold of some keramine visit Willisworms (very few
bait companies sell it and it is on a special deal there.

My web blog Bass Fish

Anonymous said...

"Worked All Zones Award" is the same concept with time zones.
This means that everyone in the whole wide world can access this new kind of radio
and you are assured that the programs as well as
the list of radio stations you are listening to are all automatically updated.
But mostly BBC Radios 4 and 5 because, being speech orientated, they're more like what I do, so I can learn lots from them.

my website :: radio rock revolution ()

Anonymous said...

a Bruce Lee workout includes stretching, bending, running,
dipping, kicking, jumping, traditional muscle building exercises,
weight lifting, rope skipping, medicine ball handling, etc.

Withdrawal from levothyroxine can be done but it takes 6 weeks of withdrawal for the remaining thyroid
tissue to be completely starved. Then leave it a
while until your tummy lets you know that you're hungry again before opting for a healthy snack.

my web site ... - -

Anonymous said...

Wanda Edwards knows cake like it's nobody's business.
Couples only fool themselves if they think guests
only care about the cake. Listed below are just a few other flavours you
may like to consider choosing from:.

Feel free to surf to my homepage cake art salisbury md []

Anonymous said...

Though the levels look really simple, they are actually quite challenging.

Caution: when a hole is made in a can, there may
be metallic edges that can cut one's mouth. The tables used for this unique drinking game can in fact be purchased commercially.

Also visit my homepage Nebraska Game And Parks Department - -

Goldman Sachs Information, Comments, Opinions and Facts